A Year After the Thalys Attack And Still No Answers on Ayoub El Khazzani

2BA6F11200000578-3210351-Moroccan_gunman_Ayoub_El_Khazzani_is_marched_into_a_Paris_courth-a-1_1440519650346

I was in the bookstore the other day and noticed a new book on the shelves of the Current Affairs section titled, “The 15:17 to Paris: The True Story of a Terrorist, a Train, and Three American Heroes” by Anthony Sadler, Alek Skarlatos, Spencer Stone, and Jeffrey E. Stern.  I pulled it off with interest because I had recently been doing my own research on Ayoub El Khazzani, the perpetrator of the attack and hoped to pick up some new information.  Sadly, there didn’t seem to be anything new in the book on that front, but it’s probably a good a time as any to lay out to you what I have found.

One of the reasons I wanted to look back at this story from August 2015 is that so little has come to light since it all happened.  To recap the event, Moroccan-born Ayoub El Khazzani boarded the Thalys train at the Gare du Midi station in Brussels on its way to Paris from Amsterdam.  Shortly after watching a Youtube video exhorting the faithful to violent jihad on a phone activated that day, he emerged shirtless at approximately 5:45pm from one of the toilets armed with an AKM assault rifle (and 270 rounds), a pistol, and a bottle of petrol.  Two individuals unsuccessfully engaged El Khazzani, who shot one of them in the neck with his pistol.  When he went to use the rifle, it jammed.  At that point, two American servicemen and their friend tackled El Khazzani.  El Khazzani slashed one of the men with a boxcutter, nearly severing his thumb.  One of the other men grabbed the AKM and beat El Khazzani in the head with the stock until he was unconscious.  A British passenger and a French train driver also came to the men’s aid, holding the attacker down.

The heroic actions of those who stood up to El Khazzani mask an uncomfortable truth of this story.  To put it bluntly, if the rifle had functioned properly we would be discussing a catastrophe instead of a near miss.  We often forget just how many of these “near misses” we’ve had—the shoe bomber Richard Reid, the underwear bomber Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, and so on.  One little detail, one minor thing in one direction or the other makes the difference between life and death.  But I digress.

My interest here is the person of El Khazzani and how he comes to be the man who tries to do this.  He was born on September 3, 1989, in the Moroccan city of Tétouan.  His father, Mohamed, a 66-year-old scrap dealer moved to Spain sometime in the Nineties and legalized his status there around 2005.  He moved the whole family (mother Zahara Acchoud, brother Imran, and sisters Oumaima, Salma, and Houda) over in 2007, settling first in Madrid before moving to Algeciras and taking up residence in the Calle Federico García Lorca (El Saladillo).  He left school very early working odd jobs and ultimately becoming entangled in the drug culture.  Ayoub appears to have stayed in the capital where he had two run-ins with Spanish authorities in 2009 for possession and sale of hashish.  He was busted again in 2012 trafficking drugs between Morocco and Cueta, one of the Spanish possessions on the coast of North Africa.  He ultimately joined his family in Algeciras and life began to calm down for him.

Ayoub’s family worshiped at the Taqwa mosque in the Piñera neighborhood, a converted auto body shop where his father served as caretaker.  The mosque stands outside the mainline Islamic community in the country, which makes it a matter of concern to Spanish authorities in a city noted as a “nest” of jihadism within the country.  Ayoub and his brother became regulars.  His life was taking a more religious turn since his stint in prison, and while he continued to hang out with young men from the street, neither he nor his brother took part in their more “sinful” activities.

It is said that Ayoub’s brother, Imran, was suspected of preaching jihad at the mosque, which may be the real reason behind his surprising deportation to Morocco in 2013.  The authorities said that his residency permit had expired, but I doubt they would have expended the effort on him apart from their other suspicions.  Family friends say the change in Ayoub became more pronounced at this point.

In 2014 El Khazzani secured a three month contract with Lycamobile in France (Seine-Saint-Denis) as part of their “ethnic marketing” business.  He began on February 3 but was terminated after exactly two months because he lacked the necessary papers to continue working in the country.  At the time he began work in France, Spanish intelligence alerted its French counterparts to El Khazzani’s presence and its concerns about his activities and relationships to jihadist networks.  The Spaniards believed that he had been radicalized during his time in prison.  The French subsequently made him a fiche ‘S’ subject.

Here the story becomes quite murky and his movements difficult to trace.  News reports say that he lived 5-7 months in Aubervilliers in 2014.  Afterwards he spent time in Cologne, moved to Vienna, then returned to Cologne before going to Brussels where his sister Oumaima (“Oum Badr”) and her family lived.  He also traveled to Andorra at some point.  The dates of his stays at the various locations are not publically known, but his time in Brussels provides some interesting possibilities for his further radicalization.

Sister Oumaima, her husband Karim, and their daughter lived in a fourth floor apartment at Chaussee de Gand 60 in Molenbeek.  The family was not officially domiciled at this location but had lived there for approximately five years as a favor from a family friend living in the rue de l’Escaut.  According to a neighbor named Rachid, Ayoub had been visiting and sporadically living at the apartment for a year and a half by the time of the attack.

This apartment is literally two doors away from rue Ransfort 3, the headquarters of Tamimi SPRL, a company co-owned by Mohamed Abrini until December 5, 2014.  While no solid connection has been made to my knowledge between El Khazzani and Abrini, some in the press have speculated that this is simply too much to have just been coincidence.  Reports also state that Ayoub frequented the mosquée Loqman, a little further down the street at rue Ransfort 24, when in Brussels.  This mosque is noted for being outside mainstream Muslim community control and is described as “radical” by the Belgian Federal Prosecutor, Eric Van der Sypt.  It turns out that the Abdeslam brothers and Abdelhamid Abaaoud also lived quite near and used the mosque as a meeting place when all still lived in the area.  Chakib Akrouh, who died with Abaaoud in Saint-Denis, attended the mosque, and Khalid Zerkani, the notorious recruiter from Molenbeek, is alleged to have held meetings at the location.

An interesting coincidence I noticed while researching this article involves that neighbor I mentioned earlier, Rachid.  As far as I can tell, the only mention of him comes in this La Capitale article, and no further detail is given about him.  Oddly enough, Abrini’s business partner at Tamimi is named Rachid Miyouf.  Like Abrini, Miyouf sold his ownership stake in the business to Mustapha Chaibi in December 2014.  Yet, the Sunday following the attacks in Paris, news reports say that Abrini’s former business partner was arrested at rue Ransfort 3 as part of the sweeping raids conducted in the aftermath.  This suggests that although Miyouf was no longer in business there, he may have still been living in that location.  Could he be the neighbor familiar with El Khazzani?  Is there something more to Miyouf that we should know?

Those sorts of questions get to the heart of the problem with the El Khazzani story.  Apart from the flood of stories which emerged in the few days after his identity was revealed, the public has learned next to nothing in the intervening year.  Probably the most important revelation concerned his travel to Turkey (and possibly Syria) in mid-2015.  His status as a fiche ‘S’ subject set off alarm bells when he attempted to board a Germanwings flight from Berlin Tegel to Istanbul on May 10, 2015.  A search of his person was conducted, but nothing found, and he was allowed to proceed.  Furthermore, we discovered that he returned to Europe just under a month later on June 4, going from Antakya to Tirana, Albania, via Istanbul.  Apart from a recent series of raids (in Molenbeek, Woluwe-Saint-Lambert and Haren) and six arrests on June 20, 2016, related to the Thalys attack, there has been virtual radio silence.

There have been no details about who he met in the Spanish prisons that may have contributed to his development, nothing about radical relationships within the Taqwa mosque, precious little about the dates of his travels throughout Europe or particulars about his living arrangements in the various cities, nothing about any friends or associates, and no details about how he procured his weaponry.  The proximities, the travel patterns, and the behaviors cry out for something bigger than what we’ve been shown.  How long do we have to wait until this story can be told?

Note: In just the last day, Le Figaro has published a story on El Khazzani, but unfortunately I do not have a subscription.  I’m curious as to whether anything new will emerge from it.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “A Year After the Thalys Attack And Still No Answers on Ayoub El Khazzani

  1. PhM September 17, 2016 / 5:08 am

    Le Figaro, no. 22403
    Le Figaro, samedi 20 août 2016, p. 11
    Société

    Attaque du Thalys : Ayoub El Khazzani reste une énigme
    Un an après l’attentat dans le train Amsterdam-Paris, les enquêteurs peinent à identifier les soutiens du tireur, un islamiste marocain de 25 ans.

    Négroni, Angélique
    page 11
    TERRORISME Charlie Hebdo et l’Hyper Cacher, le 13 novembre 2015 à Paris et à Saint-Denis, suivis des attaques à Nice et à Saint-Étienne-du-Rouvray. Ces dates qui sont désormais inscrites dans l’histoire de notre pays, parmi les pages les plus sanglantes de ces dernières années, feraient presque oublier qu’entre-temps, un carnage a été évité de justesse.

    Ce dimanche, cela fera en effet un an que le courage d’une poignée d’hommes a empêché ce qui aurait pu être un massacre. Ce vendredi 21 août 2015, Ayoub El Khazzani, un Marocain de 25 ans né à Tétouan, s’engouffre, lors d’un arrêt à Bruxelles, dans le Thalys Amsterdam-Paris avec, sur lui, un véritable arsenal. Il est en possession d’un fusil d’assaut de type kalachnikov, de neuf chargeurs de 30 cartouches contenant au total 270 munitions, d’un cutter mais aussi d’une arme de poing et d’un bidon d’essence. Avec une valise contenant ces armes, il s’enferme dans les toilettes, non loin de la voiture numéro 12. C’est là qu’il est repéré par deux passagers. En sortant quelques instants plus tard, Ayoub El Khazzani se trouve nez à nez avec deux hommes. Le premier l’empoigne fermement tandis que le deuxième, Mark Moogalian, lui arrache des mains la kalachnikov (lire ci-dessous) . Parvenant à se libérer, Ayoub El Khazzani fait feu avec son arme de poing sur Mark Moogalian, qui est grièvement blessé. Le tireur est ensuite maîtrisé par trois Américains, Spencer Stone, Alek Skarlatos et Anthony Sadler mais aussi par le Britannique Chris Norman. Tous des héros.

    Un an plus tard, l’enquête ne semble guère avoir progressé. Écroué en région parisienne, à Bois-d’Arcy, Ayoub El Khazzani, qui refuse de s’exprimer, reste l’unique mis en examen dans ce dossier. Pourtant, les investigations ne manquent pas, puisque, pour ces mêmes faits, deux enquêtes sont menées conjointement, l’une à Paris et l’autre à Bruxelles.

    Depuis le début, les enquêteurs sont persuadés qu’Ayoub El Khazzani, qui s’était installé dans la banlieue bruxelloise, a bénéficié de soutiens importants. Cet homme au profil de petit délinquant, passé à l’islam radical en Espagne où il a vécu et fiché « S » en France, se serait forcément appuyé sur un réseau. Or aucun nom de ceux qui ont surgi depuis dans des affaires terroristes ne semble lié à Ayoub El Khazzani. Les enquêteurs poursuivent donc les recherches. En juin dernier, des perquisitions ont ainsi été menées dans trois communes de l’agglomération de la capitale belge, à Molenbeek, Woluwe-Saint-Lambert et à Haren. En vain. Les six personnes interpellées ont été relâchées sans inculpation. « Par ailleurs, une coopération internationale entre autorités judiciaires est toujours en cours avec l’Allemagne, l’Espagne, la Turquie et le Maroc » , indique un proche de l’enquête. Avant d’être arrêté, Ayoub El Khazzani avait vécu ou séjourné dans ces pays. En 2015, il avait ainsi rejoint la Turquie, sans doute pour passer en Syrie.

    Avant de se murer dans le silence, juste après son arrestation, Ayoub El Khazzani avait déclaré qu’il était SDF, vivant aux abords de la gare du Midi à Bruxelles et à proximité de laquelle il avait trouvé une valise contenant des armes. L’idée d’un braquage dans un train lui était alors apparue. En somme, selon lui, rien à voir avec une attaque terroriste.

    Like

    • whoisnumber2 September 17, 2016 / 10:45 am

      Thanks for this. It appears the official investigators don’t have anything new to tell us.

      Like

  2. Vince Koers February 11, 2018 / 1:32 am

    It is now a year and a half later… Has any disposition been made of this case?

    Like

    • whoisnumber2 February 11, 2018 / 10:21 am

      Hopefully I’ll have a new post on this soon. There has been some movement thanks to the story of Bilal Chatra (or Bilal C. as he often appears in press accounts). El-Khazzani has admitted that he used the migrant route into Europe, traveling with Abaaoud, on the back of the “scouting” done by Chatra.
      There have been a couple of arrests/charges in relation as well. Mohamed Bakkali, a logistics guy in the Paris/Brussels attacks, has been charged in connection to the Thalys attack. He apparently picked up Chatra and el-Khazzani in Cologne and brought them back to Brussels. Youssef Siraj has also been arrested for providing lodging to el-Khazzani. Historically, he was sentenced in a shooting rampage with one of the el-Bakraoui brothers back in the 2009/2010 timeframe.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s